When would you guess policy-makers within the United Kingdom first considered banning coal for environmental reasons?
Barbare Freese opens her informative book – Coal: A Human History – by describing noblemen visiting London in 1306 and being appalled by the degradation of local air quality by coal burning by blacksmiths and artisans. In response, Edward I banned the use of the fuel, ordering that first offenders be punished with “great fines and ransoms” while second offenders were to have their furnaces smashed.
Obviously, coal was a niche fuel at the time. Now, the world is using more than ever before, mostly for electricity generation. That being said, if is interesting and perhaps a bit heartening to know that the harm done to human beings by coal has been recognized for more than 700 years, as has the possibility of states restricting its usage.
Strange – to me it’s the exact opposite of heartening…that the harm posed by coal was recognized so early on and yet…what happened, happened anyway. It just seems so characteristic of the most terrifying aspects of the “situation” that is being alive on earth.
That said, where would we be if coal really had been banned in 1300s England? I certainly wouldn’t be around to find out…
Banned to any lasting effect, that is.
Edward I recognized correctly that coal has serious downsides. That was not, however, enough to overcome its eventual usefulness for firing steam engines and iron foundries. Now, we have other sources of energy we can tap, and far more reason to be concerned about coal.
As for an alternative history without coal, I have thought about that a bit.
“The potentially deadly nature of urban smoke had been demonstrated… during London’s historic “Black Fog” of December 5-9, 1952. A temperature inversion trapped the [coal] smoke near the ground… Many of the 4,000 or so people killed in this episode never made it to the hospital but died in the streets; fifty bodies were removed from one small city park. In 1956, after nearly seven hundred years of complaints about coal smoke in London, Parliament finally banned the burning of soft coal in the central city, and the air immediately improved.”
Freese, Barbara. Coal: A Human History. (p. 168 hardcover)
My full review of Freese’s book is here: Coal: A Human History.
For the first time in 130 years, Britain’s electricity network generated power over a full day without having to use coal. The linchpin of the Industrial Revolution, coal now fuels only around 10% of Britain’s electricity generation as coal-fired power stations are gradually phased out.